Most Overrated Game

First of all, I want to make it clear that this should be a healthy argument without flaming. This is purely opinion on the most overrated game. If you give an overrated game, give a reason why you think it's overrated. If you disagree with someone, give reasons why. But do not get out of control with the arguments. Just want to make that clear.

Personally, I'm thinking Super Mario Galaxy at the moment.

It was an okay game. It was relatively easy (can be beaten in a matter of days with a healthy amount of hours put into it). It felt kind of repetitive, in my opinion. The 3D, Galaxy-type platforming is something I find rather annoying and not quite as revolutionary as it's made out to be.
But most of all, it gets praised like there's no tomorrow. I've even heard talk of people calling it the best game ever, which is ridiculous. Even if you like the game, you have to admit that there are a lot of retro games that deserve that title much more.

Oh boy, THIS is gonna get interesting REAL quick. Also, agreed Firus. I keep hearing things like "YOU CANNOT BE A GAMER WITHOUT PLAYING IT! IT IS GOD GAME, LOLOLOLOL." ... Oookay then... But anyways, people really need to get over it. There is NO such thing as a perfect game, and chances are there never will be (even though Portal comes pretty close )

Firus, I agree with it being easy and that it istruly overrated, but I enjoyed it while I played it (YAY LUIGI) but after I finished it it was just another game in my collection. Brawl is a very good game, and very overrated (in a bad way

Spoiler:

)

Xykonaut, do you remember this "KILL THEM, THEY'R DIFFERENT!!!!!"

salads wrote:

Xykonaut, do you remember this "KILL THEM, THEY'R DIFFERENT!!!!!"

Hahaha, how could I forget that?

Halo 3 is currently the only overrated game that comes to mind. I just love them all, lol.

Mario Galaxy WAS good- to an extent.